What does AI change in leadership?

Do we still need middle managers in the age of AI – and if so, how many?

Märt Treier recently invited me onto his radio programme to talk about the future of leadership and of leaders. One of his questions has stayed with me ever since: do we still need middle managers in the age of AI – and if so, how many? The next few years will no doubt bring a flood of academic and consultancy-flavoured books and blogs on the subject. For now, I still have the luxury of thinking it through without being unduly influenced by them.

My first answer is that I don’t know what will change. What I am convinced of is that people, at their core, do not change. Everything to do with our humanity and with the “why?” questions will stay largely the same. What will shift dramatically, though, are people’s skills and tools. Which means every “how?” question is in flux.

The second line of thinking is that Covid, the sudden growth of remote work and the rise of AI do not add up to an entirely new kind of leadership – they amplify both good leadership and bad. The need for leaders is not going anywhere; what changes is that the leader’s role becomes steadily more human-centred.

So what does change?

First, routine tasks and control functions (drawing up rotas, reviewing work and so on) matter less and less in a leader’s job. AI – and, more importantly, people themselves – often handle them better. In that situation, a leader who wades into technical detail quickly starts to look like a micromanager.

Second, the leader’s monopoly on information is cracking – the assumption that the leader knows more than everyone else and therefore holds a privileged position. Many leaders still use their command of information to manipulate and to shore up their power. In much of the work that involves information, AI is far more effective than any leader: analysis, separating the important from the trivial, forecasting. What remains with the leader is the decision that follows. If a new technology choice pushes the price up but supports a cleaner environment and, according to AI, helps the organisation’s reputation too, it is still the leader, not the machine, who has to choose between the options.

Third, the more information there is, the more important it becomes to cope with ambiguity and with ethical dilemmas. How do you balance the interests and needs of stakeholders, employees included? What long-term effect will one decision or another have on people, and what is its real price? If we accept that we need neither drastically fewer leaders nor drastically more, but different ones, then what kind? Let me open that up through the leader’s changing roles.

Creator of clarity


This role is not new, nor is it a product of the AI age. Covid brought the need for it into sharp relief, because in remote work you could no longer judge someone’s contribution by “bums-on-seats hours”, only by results. There was a crying need for leaders to spell out clearly what they expected, what mattered most, and what they would take responsibility for.

Using AI amplifies the need for essentially the same role. Many routines – including some decisions – are moving into the hands of technology. You cannot tell technology to “do it roughly like this”. Technology demands clear answers: what result you want, how you prioritise competing interests, which considerations outweigh others. People have always asked leaders these questions, but with a person a leader can often escape behind a vague answer – and the work still gets done. A machine is harder to escape. So AI does not reduce the need for the leader as a creator of clarity; it makes that role more visible and more unavoidable.

Creator of certainty

The leader is still accountable – even when decisions have been delegated or backed up by AI recommendations. In a fast-changing environment, what gives people confidence never changes: knowing who makes the hard decisions, who takes responsibility, and who they can turn to when things get difficult.

AI can speak supportively – and often does it very well – but it will not stand up for an employee. Nor does it carry the responsibility when a decision turns out to be wrong. Providing that sense of security is, and will remain, the leader’s role.

Creator of meaning

Why do we do this work? What gets better because of it? How does my work connect to my own beliefs and values, and to the ones we share? I see these questions becoming ever more important to people at work – and often there is no answer to hand.

AI can be a pocket coach, but it does not build moral lighthouses. Creating psychological safety and work that means something – helping people see why what they do matters, even when the answers are not black and white – is the leader’s job.

Builder of the learning environment

How do we learn? How do we experiment? How do we learn from mistakes and turn one person’s experience into shared team knowledge? The number of opportunities to learn is growing by leaps and bounds, but for an organisation to survive, learning has to be faster than the change around it. That does not happen by itself.

The leader’s job is to build learning into the routines: create space for experimenting, allow mistakes, and make learning a conscious, shared process – not a random by-product that may or may not happen. AI does not ask, and does not care, what kind of culture a leader creates in a team. That is the leader’s task. AI can help describe what the desired norms of behaviour might be and what people agree on, but culture begins where those agreements have to be put into practice: what happens when they are followed, and what happens when they are ignored. And there the leader is on their own – either doing the right things or not.

Author: Toomas Tamsar PCC, leadership coach

JAGA POSTITUST

veel samal teemal

Screenshot 2025-11-05 at 18.16
Belief as the backbone of a successful working relationship
IMG_1060
I love my job!
IMG_5381 (1)
A leader is a mirror of the organisation's culture
IMG_5020
My people don’t take responsibility – is this part of the Soviet-era legacy, or just another snowflake problem?
TÜ
Look at the world knowing that anything is possible!

meie sisekoolitused

The training focuses on exploring leadership competencies, working through challenges and the leader’s role in developing people.

On the training we look at what a modern development, or collaboration, conversation could look like, where the company’s plans and the employee’s own wishes meet.

The training focuses on exploring leadership competencies, working through challenges and the leader’s role in developing people.

In this training course we share practical guidance on how to keep pace with the digital world and put its many possibilities to work in your own job.

The values workshop helps you see whether your business really lives up to the values it presents to the world.

In the workshop we take your strategy apart piece by piece and put it back together again, better. You will also get the tools to create or refresh a strategy yourself.