I have spent a long time thinking about why we talk about value conflicts in leadership all the time — and who actually needs values in an organisation.
In his book “The Values-Driven Organization”, Richard Barrett writes that values are really nothing more than human needs. Values change because our wants and needs change over the course of a life. It is the same with organisations. When strategic direction and goals shift, values shift with them. Values are not words in some document or on an office wall; they have a definite role in a company’s strategy.
According to Barrett, everything begins with a person’s beliefs, which take shape during the first 24 years of life. They are the set of things a person holds to be true, and those “truths” start accumulating in childhood.
Take a family where you may only speak when you are given permission — otherwise punishment follows. A child who grows up in that family carries the pattern into school, into work and into life in general. They will most likely wait for the moment their opinion is asked for, keeping their thoughts to themselves until then. Often their turn never comes; time runs out first. A belief like that is very hard to change. What can shift it is positive attention, positive experience and recognition for speaking up.
People behave according to their beliefs. In the example above, that person’s value might be obedience, or being heard. They would probably be troubled by interruptions, people talking over one another, arguments and pushback.
An organisation is made up of people. So to make the right decisions and choices, leaders first need to understand their people’s values and the beliefs behind them, because it is the beliefs that drive behaviour.
Shared values can cause conflict
Seemingly identical values paired with drastically different beliefs make a perfect breeding ground for discord.
If Mari believes that telling the truth makes her life simple, and her value is honesty, she will say things exactly as they are, even if it hurts someone.
Liina believes you should say as little as possible and as much as necessary, because otherwise things may turn against you. Outright lying, though, is out of the question. Her value is honesty too.
They share the same value. The day Mari hires Liina, both confirm that honesty matters to them and that it connects them. Before long, Mari discovers that Liina has left things undone and said nothing about it. And there is the conflict.
Radically different readings of the same values can easily reach a point where working together is no longer possible. So is this a conflict of values or of beliefs?
When recruiting, the first thing to establish is whether our needs match. If they do, then find out the beliefs behind those wants and needs, because those are what people will act on later.
Building a successful organisational culture
Values and behaviour patterns create the culture around us and give us a sense of what is allowed and what is not. They are identity. Even if a company decides it has no need for values, every organisation has them all the same. Whether you as a leader know how your company looks to someone walking in off the street is another matter. What are the real values?
Barrett Value Center’s methodology helps you see which values and behaviours are visible and dominant in an organisation. It often turns out that, once you look at the results, it is precisely the values and behaviour patterns that are holding the organisation back.
The second important angle of the methodology is connecting people’s personal values with the company’s. The greater the overlap, the stronger the culture. It also sets out to identify what people will need in future, so they can be their best selves in your company. Combine the results and you have enough data to shape new values and behaviours that move you forward.
When embedding values, it is important to remember:
- Values are needs, and they change over the course of a life.
- Values and behaviours are part of the strategy; their role is to help the organisation meet its goals and realise its dreams.
- Every organisational culture has values. To embed new ones, you first have to understand which values and behaviours are in play right now.
It is important to understand how much overlap there is between people’s personal values and the values of the culture. It is also worth examining whether the culture holds behaviours that limit development. Leaders have to be the carriers of the values and the role models.
If you want to find out whether your organisation’s current values match its needs and ambitions, help is at hand from Nobel People’s values workshop. Get in touch!
Author: Kristiina Tukk PCC, leadership coach