I recently found myself witnessing a rather similar heated argument. Coaching vs mentoring – which is better, and how far may the two be combined? Naturally, one side was a coach and the other a mentor. Both are at a point in their careers where they have developed a deep belief in the rightness of the path they have chosen. That kind of conviction is a fine thing: compelling and inspiring.
Seen from a potential client’s point of view, though, a debate like that can be quite confusing. Arguing over methodological differences rarely brings a client much clarity. Since I have been asked myself what the difference between coaching and mentoring is, and which one to choose, let me set out my own view briefly. I make no claim to a single truth either. It is worth saying that I have worked with roughly 500 clients as a coach, and with about a tenth of that number as a mentor.
Let me begin with the observation that, to my mind, the two have far more in common than not. Both methods set out to help another person grow and develop through a personal relationship and the giving of responsibility. Both often draw on much the same tools, too – listening, reflecting, questioning and so on. Now to the differences.
How much you steer
A coach does not usually put forward solutions. The premise is that, with listening, questions and other techniques used together, people are capable of finding better solutions themselves. Sharing your own experience amounts to showing the solution, and in my view that should be avoided. A mentoring relationship, as I see it, is closer in nature to the relationship between an experienced and a less experienced colleague. Drawing on their own experience and knowledge, a mentor can help the person they are guiding avoid the pitfalls and give them confidence in choosing their path.
From my own experience of life, I would say that using experience to steer the person you are guiding is the quicker and slightly easier route. It is easier to offer and easier to accept. People often turn to a coach or a mentor for solutions when they find themselves on uncertain ground, and someone else’s experience helps them move on faster and more easily. What a coach offers, on the other hand, involves more looking inwards and more awareness of your own choices. That route calls for greater patience, but the results can be sharper self-awareness and a real understanding of why this particular solution is the best one for the person being guided.
Sharing experience as a last resort
As a coach, keeping your own experience to yourself takes effort – especially when the person in front of you is presumably experienced, as leaders are, and coaches too. You have to keep reminding yourself that all I can talk about are MY experiences of MY situations, reinforced by MY interpretations. Another person’s situation is never the same. It is also easy to reach out a helping hand and describe your own solution the moment the person you are guiding gets stuck. But that should be resisted. Staying in the uncomfortable zone of searching and half-light is harder, and it demands more trust in the person you are guiding.
From time to time I have tested a client’s trust in me by asking: Would you like me to share my experience of this? Out of a few dozen occasions, I have had a no only once. By sharing my experience I offer a lifeline that in all likelihood isn’t even needed – but it is more comfortable. Which raises the question: So can a coach share experience after all? Yes – but it has to be done consciously. Once you take on the role of Sharer of Experience, it is hard to step out of it.
Defining the task and the relationship
In my experience, coaching and mentoring also differ in how tightly the task and the relationship are bounded in time. Coaching relationships are usually defined more precisely – six months, a year, some shorter or longer period. With mentoring, stories of a lifelong guide are not unheard of. It is not an everyday occurrence, but a far longer relationship with much looser boundaries is fairly common. A coaching relationship also tends to have clearer goals – developing professional skills or personal growth.
The guide has to develop too
Both coaches and mentors have to keep building their skills. It is lifelong learning. When someone wants to help a colleague or anyone else through a one-to-one relationship without any training, they usually end up on the mentor’s path. I have noticed this in Nobel’s training courses too, where we teach leaders practical coaching skills. In the practice sessions, the leaders taking part tend to support the other participant from their own experience. When a young leader has no experience of coaching, a mentoring relationship can be a somewhat faster and more effective way to help the other person build momentum.
So should the two – coaching and mentoring – be kept apart? In the end it is simply a matter of school of thought, or of taste. I know coaches for whom the mentor’s role is entirely out of the question. But I have seen the opposite as well: experienced mentors using an approach borrowed from coaching. My own view is that you should use whatever is needed at the time. Where possible I prefer a coaching relationship, but if it is called for, we agree a mentoring or hybrid relationship with the client.
If you would like guidance too, or want a closer look at what coaching involves, Nobel People can help. Get in touch!
Author: Toomas Tamsar PCC, leadership coach