Somewhere along the way it became an axiom that people need and want far more feedback. Every self-respecting management magazine talks and writes about giving feedback continuously. We accept that more feedback is better. The more the better. And the interesting part is that when we read or hear about feedback, the talk is almost always about criticism or negative feedback. Nobody seems to have a problem with positive feedback. Or do they? Perhaps there is simply too little of it?
Feedback during the development conversation.
To begin with: continuous feedback is, without any doubt, better than feedback once a year in a development conversation. I don’t know where the annual model came from; I can only guess. Annual financial targets brought annual development goals, and annual bonuses tied to annual conversations. I have not seen many organisations that are happy with their employees’ commitment and where people are talked to “properly” once a year, at a development conversation. Once a year you cannot really talk “properly” – the trust barrier is too high.
But let’s try turning it around for a moment. Is constant “constructive” feedback really the foundation of learning and development? “Constructive” is another nice euphemism, one that often hides critical, negative feedback. Do people really want and need constant constructive feedback? Perhaps what they need is something else altogether?
Instead of development conversations, I recommend running collaboration conversations. In a collaboration conversation, we focus more on what motivates people, how to set good goals and how to give employees real responsibility.
Positive or negative feedback?
In their book “9 Lies About Work”, Marcus Buckingham and Ashley Goodall refer to a Gallup study that examined the link between feedback and employee commitment. It compared employees who received no feedback at all from their leaders, employees whose leaders focused mainly on what needed improving, and employees whose leaders focused mainly on what people did well. It then worked out the ratio of highly committed to highly uncommitted employees. What did it find?
Where leaders gave no feedback, the ratio was 1:20 – twenty times more uncommitted people than committed ones. That is an excellent formula for terrible leadership: pay people no attention. Real work – production, writing code and the like – surely just needs doing, after all.
Where leaders gave mainly negative feedback, the ratio was 2:1 – twice as many committed people. Not bad. Especially bearing in mind that commitment is 40 times higher than when no attention is paid at all.
Where leaders focused mainly on what works well, the ratio was 60:1 – 30 times better than with negative feedback. Given that commitment is the main driver of a team’s performance, the importance of that finding needs little explanation.
So perhaps it is not constant (constructive) feedback that people need most of all. In the end, it is attention – the sense that you matter, that things depend on you (why else would your leader be paying attention to you).
The purpose of feedback is learning and development
What is feedback for? For learning, of course. Knowing what is not working and why, we can correct ourselves, learn and get better. Or so we think. Another study followed two groups of students. In one group, the students worked on how to make their dreams a reality. In the other, students were given feedback on what they had done wrong in an earlier task and worked on a better solution. At the same time, neurologists scanned them with MRI to understand what was happening in their brains.
It turned out that in the first group – which was, in a sense, a comfort zone – the brain was highly receptive to learning. In the second, negative feedback triggered a response similar to “fight or flight”. People became tense and combative. In that state, the brain does not learn. So if the aim is learning, expecting it to happen under the stress that negative feedback creates is the wrong expectation. As an aside: “there’s nothing personal about feedback” is complete nonsense. It may feel that way to the person giving it. To the person receiving it, it is always personal.
None of this means that feedback should not be given, or that employees’ attention should not be drawn to what needs improving. It should. But it may give you something to think about when it comes to the dosage – how much critical and how much supportive feedback to give, and when. Whichever kind of feedback we are talking about, it starts with noticing.
I have worked with many leaders who wanted to get better at recognising people and giving positive feedback. And the question I hear again and again is: “I can’t just walk around patting people on the back for nothing – well done, you!” Of course you can’t. You can do it when you have something to say. And to have something to say, you first have to practise noticing what people actually do. It doesn’t have to be world-changing, but it does have to be “real”.