I began this piece with that story in order to clear up what I consider one of the most common myths about coaching — that coaching as a method is always soft and tolerates poor performance. It does not! For all its goodwill and support, coaching as a method gives the employee considerably more responsibility. And if a leader tolerates poor results, the problem lies with the leader, not with coaching.
Here I’ll set out two benefits that using coaching brings a leader: employees take on more responsibility, and you become a better person and a better leader yourself.
The two cornerstones of coaching — belief and communication
First, as I’ve already suggested, people take on more responsibility within coaching. What does that take?
You have to believe in the person. That is one of the cornerstones of coaching. Work with people you believe in, and believe in the people you work with. Show that belief in your words and in your actions. Its impact is extraordinary. In 1988 we travelled to Hungary with the mixed choir Noorus for a choir competition. Young people, not a care in the world, good wine. Before the competition, our chief conductor Ene Üleoja didn’t lecture us on what we were allowed to do and, above all, what we were not. Instead, she told us that we were clever young people and that she believed in us. She believed we would work out for ourselves what was right and what wasn’t. The result was this: we kept ourselves and each other in check, and we won the competition. But what do you do when you don’t believe in someone? This is a fairly strong statement, but in that case I think you should end the collaboration if you can. Working with a person you don’t believe in makes you harsher and less sincere, destroys their self-belief and delivers a poorer result.
You have to agree clearly with people on what they will do, when and how. An agreement means the person has consciously and willingly said: yes, this is an agreement and I am bound by that promise. What usually happens? The leader gives an instruction, clear or less clear. The person doesn’t argue, and the leader assumes an agreement is in place. It isn’t. Think for a moment how seriously we take responsibility or commit when we hear someone say „Get this done“, and what our attitude is when we ourselves say „Yes, I’ll take that on“. There are plenty of very practical tricks for reaching agreements (letting the other party put the agreement into words, for example), but they won’t fit into this piece.
Don’t take responsibility away from other people. A very typical leader’s line goes like this: „I just did it myself, it was so much quicker and easier.“ It may well have been quicker and easier this time, but that’s not how change or development happens either. Don’t push your solution, your help and your advice on people when they aren’t needed. There are few things as effective at killing motivation as a leader’s wise instructions that nobody asked for.
Coaching as a leadership method that focuses on what matters
Second, working from coaching methods makes you a better leader and a better person. Better in what sense? The kind of leader and person people want to talk to and dare to talk to. Whose thoughts people want to listen to, rather than have to.
The coaching method teaches you to listen and to ask. A senior leader said to me recently, more or less: „Yes, I know all about coaching. That’s when you don’t give the person the right answer, but steer them with questions to where you want them to end up.“ That isn’t right at all. The coaching method teaches you to listen for what genuinely matters to the other person, not for what you want to hear. It also teaches you to ask in a way that draws out the best of their thinking, experience or creativity. You can always add your own good ideas when they’re needed.
People always like their own ideas more than yours, the leader’s. Which means they put an entirely different level of commitment into making them happen.
And finally, the coaching method teaches awareness. It teaches you to notice what is going on with your colleague, with yourself, with your family, with the situation. It helps you understand the other person better, and their point of view, and to sense power dynamics and psychological safety. As a result, you learn to push your own perspective less and to treat it as the only right one less often. And once all that good has happened, you notice that people want to hear your opinion and your advice far more than before. Which is no small thing.
Let’s finish with the advert. Together with my partner Kristiina Tukk, I have taught a dozen cohorts of leaders how to apply the coaching method in leadership. We’re running it again this autumn as a two-day course. We don’t train certified coaches — we focus on coaching as a leadership method.
If your goal is leadership that drives your people’s development, get in touch! We offer both one-to-one coaching and team coaching to strengthen how well your organisation works together.